But I included it as his demise was my favorite part of the entire story.Įven if the rest of this arc is the worst piece of Warriors literature I will still love this book until the end of my days. I realize that this review was really more of a 'why I hate Onestar' rather than I review of this book which was completely on accident.

With a perfect villain and a perfect climax, I could not be happier. I must applaud the Erins for this book as they truly outdid themselves. That part of book two was so stupid and out of nowhere, I had to put the book down for a day or two before I could pick it up again.īack to book three, I apologize. If given the chance Onestar would whip out every single Thunderclan cat if he could. Do they mean how Onestar has hated Thunderclan more than any other clan since he became leader? Do they remember the time where Onestar risked the lives of his warriors and that of Thunderclans to attack and steal prey that Firestar was perfectly willing to give to them? More than any of the other leaders Onestar has hated Thunderclan the most. They weren't bad exactly, well except for the part in the second book where Shadowclan claims this special connection between Windclan and Thunderclan. Both the first and second books in this arc were rather underwhelming. Now I should get down to the actual book. Although I would also track down and kill Skystar after Onestar because they both are the worst literary characters I have ever come across. Even if it meant my own death it would be worth it to ride Starclan and the clans of Onestar.

If I was a clan cat who had lost as much as all the characters alive right now have at the end of this book.I would kill myself so that I would go to Starclan and hunt down Onestar's spirit and kill him for a final time. He chose himself over an innocent baby! I could make the argument that even Tigerstar never stooped this low, the mighty Tigerstar had more honor than Onestar. He knew Snakekit in Shadowclan was dying of yellowcough but he was more than willing to let this innocent baby die. He would let a baby die for his own pride and yes I have proof. He has refused help time and time again even if it meant his entire clan would die because he cared more about how it would make him look than he cared about the lives of others. He kept this secret all this time to make himself look better, he refused Firestar's offer of prey to make himself look strong, etc. All Onestar has ever cared about is his own self-image. And then tells said chick to go fend for herself because he knows that if his clan finds out he will be in major trouble. That disgusting pathetic excise for a leader was willing to pretty much let all the clans die because he had a one-night stand with a chick. If that doesn't tell you just how much I hate Onestar then nothing ever will. I was happier about Onestar finally being dead than I was to have the honor to have a fairly normal graduation during the height of the pandemic in 2020. As soon as it was confirmed that he was dead I put the book down and squealed as loud as I could with the most joy I have ever felt in my entire life. He's Dead! He's Dead! He's Dead! Finally, this utter piece of garbage is rotting in Hell where he belongs. It is all because ONESTAR IS DEAD! That asshole can go die in a hole, and I don't care if he is mentioned being in Starclan later on I will believe that he is in the darkforest where he belongs till the day I die. This is the absolute best book in this arc so far! And no not because of the epic battle at the end, or because Skyclan finally comes to the lake (they are my favorite clan by the way).

Warriors books vision of shadows book 3